Search

hu / en

Organic certification is not the whole story of sustainable winemaking – by Imre Fertő

Illustration: Grape Things – Pexels

 

Organic certification is not the whole story
of sustainable winemaking

Imre Fertő

Survey data from 232 Hungarian wineries show that greener practices and the ability to learn from outside knowledge are associated with organic certification. But certification does not capture every way wineries engage with sustainability.

Organic certification is often used as a visible sign of sustainable production. Yet some wineries adopt environmentally friendly practices without seeking formal certification. What helps explain the difference?

In our study, we examined survey data from 232 Hungarian wineries. We looked at environmental practices, wineries’ ability to learn from external knowledge, and the quality of their relationships with business partners. The results suggest that certification reflects more than what happens in the vineyard: it is also linked to a winery’s capacity to understand and meet formal requirements.

Greener practices matter, but so does the ability to learn

Wineries reporting more environmentally friendly field practices and production technologies were more likely to hold organic certification. A one-standard-deviation higher score in field practices was associated with an estimated 11.6 percentage-point increase in certification probability. The corresponding estimate was 9.4 points for green production technologies.

The ability to identify, absorb and apply knowledge from outside the winery was also associated with higher certification probability—by an estimated 11 percentage points for a one-standard-deviation difference.

This learning capacity may matter because certification involves more than adopting a particular farming method. Producers need to interpret standards, keep records and work with certifying bodies. Advice and clear procedures may therefore help wineries navigate the process. Our study points to these as potential barriers; it does not test whether any particular support programme increases certification.

Trust and certification may serve different roles

One finding was less expected: stronger relationships with business partners were associated with a 12.9 percentage-point lower certification probability.

One possible interpretation is that trust, reputation and repeated dealings can help establish credibility between business partners, reducing the additional value a winery sees in formal certification. But the survey does not show that wineries deliberately use relationships as a substitute for certification, or that trust causes lower uptake. We also found no evidence that relationship quality changed the link between greener field practices and certification.

The results point to a question for future research: when do business relationships support formal certification, and when might they provide a separate way to demonstrate credibility?

Certification is informative, but incomplete

These findings matter for how sustainability is measured. If certification is treated as a direct measure of environmental commitment, the efforts of uncertified producers may be overlooked. A winery may already use greener practices without having formalized them through certification.

The study is based on a one-time survey in Hungary, so its results show associations rather than cause and effect. The role of business relationships may also differ in countries where organic certification is more established. Longitudinal and cross-country studies could help show how these patterns change across settings.

Organic certification remains an important way to recognize and verify sustainability practices. But understanding why uptake varies requires looking at both producers’ environmental work and the organizational and relationship contexts in which they operate.

 

Based on Imre Fertő and Valéria Lekics,
“What drives organic certification?
Practices, capabilities, and governance in the wine sector
,”

Sustainable Futures (2026).

 

 

 

 

 

Next month >